Subscribe
The Daily Grind Video
CLOSE

This is one of those fashion situations that get just a tad bit hard to judge. 

Should one of the greatest supermodels of all time refrain from wearing a look that was rocked just 3 days earlier on the second-most watched Super Bowl ever? Or should she continue to slay in whatever she wants, because…you know, she is Naomi and she can do things like that.  

PHOTOS: Fashion Face-Off: La La Anthony vs Fergie In Givenchy

Alicia Keys and Naomi Campbell both donned the same look from Azzedine Alaia this week, Alicia in red at the Super Bowl, and Naomi in white on the red carpet for the NYC premiere of The Face.

The Tunisian-born Paris-based Alaïa has been creating seductive, curve-hugging clothes since he first opened his own Parisian atelier in the late ’70s, so it’s no surprise that celebs and models alike love the stunning fit. 

STORY: They’re Back! And This Time The Occupy Movement Is Coming For New York Fashion Week 

The politics of the repeated look is not what’s most important; the real tossup here is who donned the look better. Naomi piled her arms with glitzy accessories and an emerald ring to boot, while Alicia kept it simple with a gold choker necklace. 

Take a look at both of the ladies rocking the look in the gallery above. We are kind of torn on who will win this one.