This section requires Flash Player (version 9). You can download the Flash player here

 

News & Politricks   >> more News & Politricks

Now That's Justice, Mr. President

| 2,495 Views See Original Story >>
3
26
COMMENTS

Reacting to a rising tide of anger from gay and lesbian supporters at a series of slights and deferred promises, President Obama will tomorrow extend some benefits to same-sex partners of federal employees. The move, which begins to mirror the policy of many large corporations, will have an immediate effect for many workers, but it is a deeply reactive response to a core Democratic group whose concerns have been festering for six months. The presidential memorandum  -- scheduled for signing tomorrow at 5:45 p.m., may in the short term, give Joe Biden something positive to say at a June 25 fundraiser that has seen prominent guests drop out, a host sharply attack the administration, and which is expected to be marked by protests. However, the Defense of Marriage Act prohibits the federal government from extending health and retirement benefits to same-sex couples, so the benefits are more likely to be marginal -- like relocation assistance. The order is one of several lower-profile moves the administration had promised gay groups this month, but appears to have been announced this evening to stem rising protest. "President Obama will be signing a presidential memorandum tomorrow to provide benefits to same-sex partners of federal employees," an administration official said. The silence on gay rights in the early days of the administration have pushed many gay rights leaders toward demands that Obama go beyond smaller-bore issues toward the heavier political lifts of ending "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" and the Defense of Marriage Act and supporting same-sex marriage. And they're shifting toward a more confrontational strategy, which could include a march on Washington later this year. The executive director of the Empire State Pride Agenda, a large state-based gay rights group, Alan Van Capelle, greeted today's announcement sarcastically. "Welcome to 1999," he told POLITICO. "How revolutionary of the White House to give benefits to same-sex couples, when two-thirds of conservative Wall Street are already doing it. What an achievement." "It's just one of the things that should have been done in January," Van Capelle, who was among those taking his name off the Biden event, said, calling for a "comprehensive strategy." "If the President makes the announcement tomorrow, it will still fall short of what LGBT people are expecting from this administration." Richard Socarides, a gay former Clinton aide, called a plan to extend benefits "terrific." But Obama "will have to address 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' and the [Justice Department motion supporting the Defense of Marriage Act] at this point to give it any real meaning. People  want to know - his gay supporters want to know - why has this gone so  wrong." UPDATE: This post has been updated to note that health benefits appear not to be among those to be extended, to add comments, and to clarify that the document is formally a presidential memorandum, not an executive order. UPDATE, Take II: President Obama's plan is drawing a lukewarm reaction this morning, as it becomes clear that -- contrary to some early reports -- the benefits can't include access for same-sex partners to health or retirement plans. The Defense of Marriage Act, which Obama vowed during the campaign to repeal, prohibits the federal government from extending those benefits, so today's announcement appears likely to be limited to meaningful, but less sweeping, changes for gay and lesbian federal workers. "Are they kidding us? Domestic Partnership benefits WITHOUT health insurance because of DOMA? What kind of reality do they live in?" gay fundraiser and activist David Mixner emailed me this morning. "It is like rubbing salt in the wound. I am glad that some barriers will be lifted for Federal Employees but what is the most important benefit needed....health insurance! Good god." Even some congressional Democrats appear unimpressed by the move. Rep. Anthony Weiner of New York emailed out this lukewarm statement this morning: President Obama’s decision displays the administration’s commitment to ensuring that certain basic rights and privileges are extended to all Americans. While encouraging, this measure only grants same-sex couples benefits that have been provided by corporations for years and fails to reverse the administration's troubling refusal to fully recognize same-sex couples under the law and to allow lesbian gay bisexual trangender Americans to serve openly in the military. That said, I am still pleased to say that the unacceptable reality of offering fewer benefits to same-sex couples is about to change."

26 comments

  • EVERYONE HAS A RIGHT TO VOICE THEIR OPINIONS, HOWEVER, THAT IS ALL THEY ARE, OPINIONS!!YOUR PERCEPTION IS YOUR REALITY, WE ALL PERCEIVE THINGS DIFFERANTLY, SO OUR REALITIES ARE NOT THE SAME, WHATS REAL TO ME, MAY NOT BE REAL TO YOU, SO YOU MUST BE EASY NEXT TIME YOU PASS JUDGEMENT ON ANOTHER, INSTEAD FOCUS THAT ENERGY ON YOUR OWN REALITY.. LEARN TO CONTROL YOUR OWN DESTINY, LIFE IS WHAT WE MAKE IT...AN IN LIFE ONLY ONE THING IS GUARNTEEED AN THAT IS THE MOMENT YOU ARE IN....I AM A STRAIGHT GIRL, ITS JUST NOT ME TO BE ANY OTHER WAY...BUT WE ARE ALL DIFFERANT AND IF THIS IS WHAT MAKES THEM HAPPY, THEN SO BE IT....I HAVNT READ THE BIBLE, HOWEVER THERE ARE SOME GOOD THINGS IN IT TO LIVE YOUR LIFE BY...MYSELF, I HAVE A RELATIONSHIP WITH GOD, SOMETIMES I GROW DISTANT FROM HIM, HOWEVER THE GOD I KNOW IS ABOUT LOVE, ABOUT CHOICE, AN AS LONG AS WE ARNT HARMING OURSELVES OR ANOTHER THEN IT SHOULDNT BE AN ISSUE, MY GOODNESS ARNT THERE MORE SERIOUS THINGS TO ARGUE ABOUT? I MEAN THERE ARE PEOPLE BEING MURDERED, RAPED, MOLESTED ECT...ECT... WHY DO YOU WASTE YOUR TIME JUDGING SOMEONE FOR THEY WAY THEY CHOOSE TO LIVE THERE LOVE LIFE? COME ON PEOPLE, THIS IS JUST LIKE RELIGION!! WELL GUESS WHAT PEOPLE, JESUS WENT AGAINST RELIGION TO BRING A RELATIONSHIP WITH GOD....2 CORINTHIANS 3:13-18 HE WENT AGAINST SIN TO BRING FORGIVENESS, HIS BODY PLACED AGAINST THE CROSS IN SUFFERING TO BRING SALVATION!! HE A REBEL WITH A CAUSE!! WE R SUPPOSE TO LOVE ONE ANOTHER REGARDLESS OF COLOR, SHAPE, SIZE, RELIGION, IF YOU ARE A TRUE BELEIVER IN GOD THEN YOU WOULD HAVE A RELATIONSHIP WITH GOD AND YOU WOULD ALREADY KNOW THIS, THUS YOU WOULDNT BE WAISTING YOUR TIME JUDGEING SOMEONE BECAUSE OF HOW THEY CHOOSE TO LIVE THEIR SEX LIVES...YOU PEOPLE WHO HAVE NOTHING BETTER TO DO THEN VISUALIZING THEIR SEX ACTIVITIES....YOUR THE ONES WITH THE DEMENTED MINDS!!!! YOU NEED TO DO SOME DEEEEEP SOUL SEARCHING YOURSELVES CAUSE YOU JUST DONT GET IT..ITS SO SIMPLE, YET EVERYONE MAKES IT HARD ...I WILL PRAY FOR YOU!!!
  • The Bible states certain things are right and wrong and thats how this country has based its laws off of....Are we going to give theifs and murderers special rights too? A sin is a sin and us people that are married with aman and a women should not have our marriages downgraded by thingslike this...God gave us free will andyour choice is your choice but marriage is supposed to be a sacred act between a man and a women and the Bibly clearly states that...It also says that homosexuality is wrong just like murder lying and stealing...People wonder why this country has gone to hell
    • Homosexuals are neither thieves (not thiefs) nor murderers. So that pretty much punches a whole in your theory.
    • Not really the Bible states that homosexuality is wrong and is a sin and the Bible also says alie is the same asmurder in God's eye...a sin is a sin
    • The reason why this country is going to hell is because people like you are looking down on people who are trying to live their lives and be happy. The "bible" says a lot of things, but this is 2009 and we are looking at issues differently than back then. You can't base all laws on the "bible" because not everyone believes in the same person. You sound so ignorant. How is same sex marriage "downgrading your marriages"? They love each other just like a man and a woman do. People act like the gay, lesbian, bisexual, etc. people are a different species and we are exactly the same as you. At times, we are better because we don't look down on you like you to on us. You need to think before you say things so you don't sound like an ignorant jackass.
    • The Bible also okays having slaves and says that all animals in the universe pre-flood lived in Noah's backyard. The Bible is filled with racist, sexist and unfair remarks, as the last additions to it were added, what, over 1000 years ago?

      Times have changed. If you think Obama is doing ANY work but the work of a good, benevolent God, then you're deluding yourself. I suppose you want to kill the "heathens" in Iraq as well, don't you?
    • I do not look down on anyone. I have friends that are gay but it is still wrong. I love my friends that are in same sex marriages but that doesn't mean I have to believe it is right. And all the people that are trying to be happy are going to regret it one day when they die....Why not try to stop and redeem yourself and ask for forgiveness and go to heaven?
    • No I do not believe in a lot of what Obama is doing...but why would that have anything to do with people in Iraq? My husband is in the military and I strongly am against the war....my husband is in danger just asm uch as they are.
    • I believe that god made us all in his image if he didn't want us blacks mexicans whites asians gays bi's lesbians anything really. then guess what they wouldn't be here. If you look at the whole bible, things change with time. Pork was unclean and noone ate it because that's what it said in a book. Then in the new testament it was ok to eat it.... Times change and so do the minds of the people.
  • hey tila

    im glad obama is doin this..

    there shldnt be a rule against same-sex marriage.

    its stupid.. thts all i have to say..

    hurray for tila...XOXOOXXOXO
  • we are living in the days of the real life modern day Sodom & Gomorah! I don't hate gays or lesbians, I just dont agree to their lifestyle! Gay people expect everyone to see the world as they do! But we are different people, with different opinions and point of views. I am a christian and I do believe that the gay & lesbian lifestyle is wrong and against the laws of the bible, but I think that everyone has to give an account of their own lives here on earth. We all will meet our Maker one day and when we get before him, we have to answer to Him!
  • IF YOU DONT WANT TO SEE GLBT MARRIAGES THEN DONT GO TO THE DAMN WEDDINGS... PLAIN AND SIMPLE!!



    I'm not gay, but just the fact that there are laws against them is not right in my opinion! This is the United States of America, millions of people have died fighting for the freedom that we ALL benefit from! Not allowing GLBT marriages is DISCRIMINATION and all laws holding them back should be abolished!!!!
  • I think it's ok for bisexuals or gays to be married to whoever they feel. My bestfriend is bisexual and i know many gays and lesibans thats dont what people think or say. i feel u can love and marry who u want to its not that point that u have to live with them. It's the point that u should support them in whatever they believe.
  • ea
  • I am a lesbian mother of two and it really bothers me that no matter how hard we try we can't get the help we need because we are lesbains. I don't understand she can pay our bills and work her ass off to keep a roof over our heads but she can't get insurance for the kids and I because no matter what we think our relationship isn't seen as a real relationship in the eyes of the law. She can't be a parent to our kids because some old people with old values don't understand. Well understand this LOVE BETWEEN TWO PEOPLE *be they man and woman or man and man or like us two women* IS THE SAME AND SHOULD BE TREATED AS SUCH... WHAT ARE ALL YOU BIGGETS TRYING TO SAY THAT GOD MAD A MISTAKE BY MAKING US THE WAY HE DID.....IT IS NOT A CHOICE IT IS HOW WE WERE MADE IT IS HOW GOD MADE US STOP PUNISHING US FOR BEING HOW HE WANTED US TO BE....DO AS WE DO AND EMBRACE US A HUMAN LET US MARRIE AND BE HAPPILY IN LOVE LIKE ALL HUMANS SHOULD HAVE THE RIGHT TO DO!!!!!!!!
  • i honestly think it's stupid that people look at gays lesbians in a offensive way. i'm not lesbian, but my mom is, and the only difference between her "straight people" is that she likes women. Honestly, all the people who are against gay lesbian marriage are just ignorant. i want all you people to ask yourself how in the WORLD is someone else's life going to affect u? it's not like ur the one that's getting married to the same-sex. So let these other people live their life happily. Same-sex marriages honestly DOES NOT affect your life severly, so get over yourselves. Yes, i understand that people have religious views on this, but it just sucks that it's so stuck in people's brain that marriage should be between a man a woman. OPEN YOUR EYES PEOPLE, GAYS ARE EVERYWHERE. what difference does it make that they get married? even if prop 8 does officially pass, it's not like you won't be seeing gays & lesbians walking around places & stuff. honestly, just stop being so close-minded. if you don't want to see same-sex marriages, then don't go to their wedding. let gays and lesbians be happy just as straight people are. how would you feel if someone tried to stop u from marrying the one you love?
  • i just wanna say im a total lesbian and me n my partner are wanting to get married and spend the rest of our life together.. we are raising my son together and he loves us both a lot but it sucks that we cant get married and have the marriage name for say.... i will fight till the day i die to help lesbians and gays n whoever else be happy together and be married.....
    • so do you feel you have made the best descion for your son in giving him two mothers? Does a child really understand whats going on? Are you willing to see all the hurt he will go through during school when he's made fun of for having two mothers? Kids are cruel. I've seen this happen.. it tore my friend apart growing up, never telling her mom how she truly felt because she didn't want to hurt her mothers feelings... and now as a full grown woman she has nothing to do with her mother. Life is not easy.. we as parents shouldn't make it even harder for our children. No matter how much you love this woman and no matter how much your son loves her... it is still not a fully accepted thing in todays society and your son will fill that pain growing up,the pain of not being accepted because his mother is with a woman.. whom is also his mother? Even if he has a father he see's and knows.. he still has TWO mothers>>> Im sad for your precious son :(
    • Yeah that's life its how he deals with it. He will have all the love he needs. He will have everything he needs and most of what he wants. The problem isn't the situation. Its people like you who make it "bad". Because you don't understand. My wife loves my kids as much if not more then their father who is not here and thinks that talking on the phone once in a while is what a good dad does. My wife pays all their bills and keep happy and fed he doesn't. I don't thinks kids NEED a FATHER AND A MOTHER. I belive that they need two parents that love them.
      Look stop teaching your kids to hate and there wont be issues with it. Teach your kids to be open minded and not judgmental and they wouldn't be so cruel. Cruelty and closed minded biggetry is learned not something they just are. Sorry if this affends wait no I'm not because what you said affended me. Open your eyes and see.
    • I have something else to say. Are you saying that we should live unhappy because the world isn't ready?? f*ck that I WILL NOT SUFFER SO OTHERS FEEL BETTER.
    • I don't think there is anything wrong with being a lesbian, nor with a child having two mothers or two fathers. Kids may tease and bother; however, it's because of the intolerant behavior of parents. It is the old fashion ideas that keep us from moving forward as a society. Plus, I bet it wouldn't be too fun if heterosexual marriage was illegal. As for you Joanna, I applaud you and your partner...:)
    • f*ck you Cindy
    • me and my brother are the children of two mothers. we are both close to our parents (2 mothers and a father). ive never seen so much love in a relationship than my mom and stepmom. they got married before prop 8 passed. it never affected me in any way while i was growing up. if people didnt love my mom, my family, or anything that means the world to me, i didnt care because i love them.
    • throughout history people have been persecuted for being gay. its not a new issue. To say its wrong or indecent just because society doesnt agree with it is totally closed minded. African americans were deprived of their human rights for a long time. Was it ok just because bigots didnt think it was ok to "allow" them their human rights?! of course not. this is the same type of issue as far as im concerned...
  • -* I sure hope it does.

    Im a proud bisexual woman. & is waitinq & hopinq for chanqe. No one has the right to judqe us.? ONLY GOD HIMSELF.!



    "WILL GOD PUNISH US FOR LOVING, OR PUNISH YOU FOR HATING.?"



    I believe every individual should be happy. It doesn't matter by race, shape, or gender... EVERYPERSON deserves love & happiness. & Those who disagree; well, you have to deal with it.!



    xoxo
    • He will punish us both most likely

POST A COMMENT

or Sign In

POST TO:

submit comment